Human Ecology impact factors

Sting Operation Demonstrates the Value of Journal Impact Factors
November 5, 2015 – 03:10 pm

The recent sting operation carried out by John Bohannan of Science focuses needed attention on the shadiest practices of academic publishing. As described in his great article, Bohannan submitted a faked cancer study, riddled with errors, to 314 open access journals. The sad outcome is that 157 of the journals accepted the paper for publication.

I was curious to find out whether Journal Impact Factors, a commonly used quantitative measure of a journal’s influence (and thus prestige), would predict whether the fake article would be accepted for publication or not. Lucky for me and anyone interested in this topic, Bohannan and Science have made a summary of their data available for download.

I cross-referenced the list of journals that received the spoof paper to the Thompson Reuters Journal Citations Reports (JCR) Science Edition 2012 database. I found that the great majority of the journals that received the article are not even listed or tracked in the JCR Science database: only 44 (14%) of the journals had an entry in the JCR database. While 57% of the journals without a listing in JCR Science accepted the paper, only 7% (n=3) of those in the database did so. The two pie-charts below illustrate the outcomes of submissions to journals listed and unlisted by the JCR Science database:


Since only 3 of the journals listed in the JCR Science database accepted the paper, it is difficult to make generalizations about the characteristics of such journals. Bohannan includes in his article excerpts of emails with the editor of one of these journals, Journal of International Medical Research, who takes “full responsibility” for the poor editing.

With the caveat that samples sizes are really small, I compared the 2012 impact factors of listed journals who accepted the paper (n=3) with those who rejected it (n=34). The median impact factor of accepting journals was 0.994 and those who rejected was 1.3075 (p

You might also like
The Human Population: Factors that Affect Population Size
The Human Population: Factors that Affect Population Size
5 Human Impacts on the Environment: Crash Course Ecology #10
5 Human Impacts on the Environment: Crash Course Ecology #10
Popular Q&A
How can humans impact the ecology of organisms? | Yahoo Answers

i havent seen hoot but humans can and do impact the ecology of other organisms because we change their habitat through building our own homes and through farming etc. an example is wheat was not always the one of the most abundant crop on this planet like it is today and of course any animal that lived in areas where wheat grows now would be displaced. another example is human development often causes a decrease in the number of animals because we hunt them for food or fur or simply destroy their homes. pro of human impact on ecology would be human survival and a con would be the loss o…

Related Posts